Extracts
from reviews of Catch and Glee Culture:
Brian Robins has given
an excellent history of the forms and their cultivation in their heyday… This is a fine account of a uniquely British
repertoire… - Clifford
Bartlett, Early Music Review.
...Robins draws together a wealth of detail, correcting
some of the more hagiographic accounts and providing a meaningful social context... His book will serve as a very useful and
readable conspectus of the wrttten sources... Meanwhile, it has made me want to go and sing some more of the music, which
is no small compliment. - Mark Argent, Goldberg Early Music Magazine
In summary, Robins has produced an excellently researched book; the wealth of information in the footnotes
and appendices makes fascinating reading in its own right. It provides an excellent entrée to those who wish
to study catch and glee music itself, and it also makes a firm first mark in a hitherto barely explored area of our national
culture and heritage. - James Hobson, Chombec News, 3
It is commonplace to attribute
the greatest "English" music of the 18th century to non-native composers... While such attributions may be overly
simplistic in that they seem to gloss over the importance of native traditions, few scholars have offered anything in the
way of a corrective. Brian Robins's book is a notable exception. Undertaking a formidable amount of archival work, the
author reconstructs the culture that encouraged the development of the catch and the glee... - Stephanie Pietros, Early
Music America
Meanwhile, Robins has produced a thoroughly researched
account of a 'phenemon' that the jacket blurb claims has been 'largely overlooked by historians'. Certainly
historians should find his book a stimulating source of information on the topic; it is an important contribution to cultural
history... - Susan Wollenberg, Eighteenth-Century Music.
The
strength of Catch and Glee Culture... lies in the author's command of the sources, and the thorough, nuanced
accounts of so many institutions, repertories, and so on. Future scholars will long be indebted to him for this presentation
of material. - Christina Bashford, Music and Letters